Thanks for your help guys, but I am a little confused.
I followed the walkthrough for unlocked phones, here:
Pwnage 2.0 Guide - ModMyI - Wiki
The option-restore step didn't work. My phone currently is displaying an ipod plug with an arrow pointing to an itunes logo on it. In iTunes it says that the phone is in restore mode, but when I click option+restore and select the Pwnage .ipsw file, it won't restore.
So I can't follow that first walkthrough, because it asks me to upgrade to 2.0 and I can't restore according to the option-restore error. Is it safe to try to just click restore in iTunes? When the phone last restarted, it had the pineapple logo. Should I use the restore guide? I'm worried I'll make the scenario worse or brick the phone.