[dr33Rocks]

This is a discussion that came up in another thread but I felt like it needed some attention in it's own thread. If you have, or are thinking about upgrading/purchasing KATE then beware because the developer has locked out the use of the FACELIFT modification if you are also using WINTERBOARD. The developer, ripdev, said that kate and winterboard are not compatible together so they (ripdev) actually lock you out of using any facelift/springboard modifications if you also have winterboard installed. You literally have to uninstall winterboard to get the ability to use facelift.

Here is my problem...I HAD a perfectly functioning 3G 2.01 running Winterboard and Kate side-by-side with NO compatibility issues at all. That is why I was surprised when I updated to the most recent release of Kate and they locked me out of using the facelift option citing "compatibility" issues with Winterboard. What is even worse, there was no warning prior to the install that this was going to happen and to my knowledge there were not any new features added in the update.

At least give me a warning page that there might be compatibility concerns and I should use both applications "at my own risk". But just give me the choice either way. I sent them an email basically saying what I have just said and asked them to either send me a link to the previous version, or submit a refund...because to be honest, everything but the 'facelift' option I can get through other FREE applications via cydia and there is noooo way I am giving up my Winterboard for just a few other very minor options. I encourage those of you out there that have also purchased a license (it's worth it for the FACELIFT option) and who are a little put-off by their recent update to email them your concerns as well.

***UPDATE***
Here is the email that I received from ripdev in response to my inquiry.

Hello,

Unfortunately, both programs have similar functions and a principle of work, they cannot be compatible. Can be in the future there will be a joint decision.


Alex (alexxb5) Shirinkin
RiP Dev - The iPhone Development Company
RiP Dev: The iPhone Development Company


Seems like to me that this may be more 'politically' driven than actually 'compatibility' driven especially if you read into their last comment which said, "Can be in the future there will be a joint decision." And what does he mean, "...they cannont be compatible", that is funny because I had them both working just fine, so again makes me think there is some other motivation here. I am going to email them again because they basically didn't address my concerns and didn't respond to my request for a refund or link to previous version. It would be one thing if this were a FREE or cheap application, but when you fork over $45, crap like this shouldn't be going on.

[bbplayer5]

My kate works prefectly. If you dont want it dont use it? I like it because it doesnt effect battery or slow down my phone.

[jaf2]

I'm trying to make them work together : if i rename the "WinterBoard.app" to "WinterBoard2.app", the facelift fuction is back. But winterboard, even if it runs, dont work (no changes even if u can choose your theme).

Maybe someone can help us to modify some system files of winterboard to localize the new folder as "WinterBoard2.app" (for example). Because i'm pretty sure that the only way kate detect that winterboard is installed is that there is a "WinterBoard.app" folder in the applications folder...

[dr33Rocks]

Originally Posted by bbplayer5

My kate works prefectly. If you dont want it dont use it? I like it because it doesnt effect battery or slow down my phone.

Did I say that I didn't like it? No! I said the new update (08/21/08) will NOT let the facelift option work if you also have winterboard installed. But before the newest update, mine DID work perfectly. And if I didn't want it, I would not have paid the $45.00 for it (purchased when I was still using 1.1.4 on iphone 2G) Try reading the full post before you comment next time.

[smirkis]

try using the app from cydia that allows you to change the names of applications. should re-allow you to use facelift and keep all strings attatched so winterboard continues to work properly.

whata bust tho

[461am]

It's more likely that it recognizes winterboard through it's bundle identifier.

[jaf2]

Originally Posted by smirkis

try using the app from cydia that allows you to change the names of applications. should re-allow you to use facelift and keep all strings attatched so winterboard continues to work properly.

whata bust tho

I've already try to modify winterboard's name using renamer : didnt work

Originally Posted by 461am

It's more likely that it recognizes winterboard through it's bundle identifier.

What u mean??

[NetMage]

The bundle identifier is in the Info.plist in the WinterBoard.app folder. You can see it after the line that says CFBundleIdentifier.

You could try changing that string to com.saurik.WinterBoard2 and reboot, and see if Kate still recognizes it. I bet it is using the application folder name since facelift came back when the application folder was renamed.

WinterBoard probably ties its dynamic load into SpringBoard through its folder name, so you would need to change those hooks as well to WinterBoard2.app.

The only one I see is the symbolic link in /Library/MobileSubstrate/DynamicLibraries that links to /Applications/WinterBoard/WinterBoard.dylib

If you renamed WinterBoard.app and then fixed the dynamic link to point to the new location, than reboot, that should work I think.

[jaf2]

Originally Posted by NetMage

The bundle identifier is in the Info.plist in the WinterBoard.app folder. You can see it after the line that says CFBundleIdentifier.

You could try changing that string to com.saurik.WinterBoard2 and reboot, and see if Kate still recognizes it. I bet it is using the application folder name since facelift came back when the application folder was renamed.

WinterBoard probably ties its dynamic load into SpringBoard through its folder name, so you would need to change those hooks as well to WinterBoard2.app.

The only one I see is the symbolic link in /Library/MobileSubstrate/DynamicLibraries that links to /Applications/WinterBoard/WinterBoard.dylib

If you renamed WinterBoard.app and then fixed the dynamic link to point to the new location, than reboot, that should work I think.

Winterboard works again, but facelift dont i cant understand why, since we rename the WinterBoard.app folder...

[dellmelo]

after a few emails with RiPDev support:

We work above compatibility with the Winterboard.
Probably, it will be possible in the following version.


Alex (alexxb5) Shirinkin
RiP Dev - The iPhone Development Company
RiP Dev: The iPhone Development Company

meanwhile... use a summerboard theme.
all fine here.

[tsatryan]

There really is only one function that I like in Kate - the 5 icon dock. Freeboard had that for 1.1.4. but I am not aware of anywhere to get a five icon dock in 2.0.x other than with Kate. Any ideas?

[nickh]

Kate is the only option for now, I am as disappointed as you and many others are!

[upstateiphone]

If you paid via paypal or credit card contest it. They will give you your money back! Got to love those Russians!! Even their president has an unlocked iPhone!

[ikitten]

I was PISSED OFF when this happened to . I thought I was being petty when them but now I see I'm justified. Rip Dev never even responded. I asked for a link to the previous version and asked why they did this .Facelift was the ONLY reason I bought it and until winterboard offers 5 docks, labels and SMS privacy I'm not sure how RIPDEV can say they are alike. Uninstalling WB without warning f'd up my keyboard. I'm really PISSED I'm contemplating a refund ( this will be the 2nd) I can't believe I trusted them again.

well they responded with the same generic reply. " they are not able to work together, we will fix this option in the next update" Hmmmmm ... we will see. Anyone know what's up with iblacklist? I bought that app as well and still waiting for a 2.0 version. I tried PYSL .. but it didn't block anything ... my husband was able to get through!!! what good us that???

[artjr]

I have the 2g iphone and before the update, I had Winterboard AND kate running perfect! I was also shocked and scratching my head as to the statement that they are not compatible cause they are or were before update! I would love to get the link to downgrade to the previous version of kate.