Your favorite Apple, iPhone, iPad, iOS, Jailbreak, and Cydia site.
05-20-2010, 12:20 AM #61
The problem has been that a few "trusted" beta members have relaesed the files, although most of this comes from people who buy one copy legit and think that gives them the right to treat it like their property and distribute it as they see fit...
Last edited by TCcentex; 05-20-2010 at 06:02 AM.
05-20-2010, 02:03 AM #62
05-20-2010, 04:22 AM #63
I understand the issues the themers are facing and find it very sad that this turn of events will cause some themes to never be finished.
However, I think this whole idea of trying to watermark/protect ones themes is silly.
- First, you'll never make a crack proof protection, NEVER!
Just think about it, any software/game can be cracked on pc.
This is the same for all apps on appstore.
Why do you think you'll manage to find a decent protection for themes?
- Second, protecting further encourages cracking followed by distribution.
In the sense that whoever cracks your software/theme does it for credits and recognition, hence will offer cracked version to as many as possible.
- Third, trying to protect your stuff ends up in making you the "bad guy". The end user tends then to have less remorse for stealing your work.
On the contrary, I think the focus must be placed on informing and responsibilizing the users that your theme came with a lot of work, hence the small fee asked to support you in the creation of the next theme.
There will still be piracy and theft, you can't fully prevent this, though on a lower scale if more people feel remorse for doing so.
What I feel is that all the new themers are now only coming for the gain they expect to get selling their themes.
Forgetting that all the great themers here who are now selling very complete and polished themes on cydia also proposed many finished and nice looking free themes.
I guess the continuous lack of free themes and growing nr of pay themes is a vector in the increase of theft.
In conclusion, my 2 cent is that I think it's better to focus on Donations and the importance of contributing through it, that trying to sell themes through cydia and protecting them.
05-20-2010, 07:37 AM #64
The themes will always be leaked, and I'm starting to at least hope that 99% of the people leaking and licking the theme droplets off the floor are young kids who don't have the means or cool enough parents that will boost them a couple bucks. I just wish there weren't so many supposed "Legitimate" sites out there that give these leakers a forum to do their dirty work. Shouldn't it be a back-alley, torrent kind of thing? Seeing leaked themes all over other iPhone forums is truly disheartening. MMi just rocks like nobody's business.
05-20-2010, 07:46 AM #65
05-20-2010, 08:23 AM #66
not only has this thread been made a sticky, but its also become a play were we are able to appreciate everybodies hard work.
thank you for your support!
alright, ive updated the front post with a list of themes leaked :/ its pretty big, and i know theres more post more if you find them.
Last edited by RelentlessDan; 05-20-2010 at 08:23 AM. Reason: Automerged Doublepost
05-20-2010, 08:36 AM #67
To add to Madbat's comment, I'd like to point out that not only are there idiots who sell pirated themes (including one or two who ripped off Bars' work), but the ones who sell 'themes' which are a lockscreen wallpaper or simple icon sets are on the rise.
That, on top of people being cheap, may be contributing to the rise in theme piracy as the glut of paid themes of those two types is helping assuage the consciences of those stealing the themes, as they lump themers like Bars or k.nitsua and zausser with the lot that does those wallpaper or icon sellers, assuming that because those 'themes' cost the same, that they have equally little content and effort to pay for.
Mind you, there are people who wouldn't pay even if refusing would get them killed...
The Following User Says Thank You to Jarlath For This Useful Post:
05-20-2010, 09:09 AM #68
I don't think we should post a list of themes that have been leaked I feel like that's promoting warez just saying though I know this thread kind of does that already making a list just seems like too far
05-20-2010, 09:11 AM #69
hmm i never saw it like that.
okay list deleted now, theres a few listed but nothing that wasnt listed originally!
The Following User Says Thank You to RelentlessDan For This Useful Post:
05-20-2010, 09:33 AM #70
05-20-2010, 10:23 AM #71
Well I finally drank the cool-aid. I had a nice little string of tyraids on that other x-rated site, and I've come to the conclusion that the best way to combat this issue is to simply ignore it. I perused the forum threads over there and found numerous people who dowloaded cracked themes that are now great MMi contributors and followers of the very themes they "stole", so these people that test-drive it before buying it are definitely out there. It's just inevitable, and I don't think anyone's close to quitting their jobs and living off their theming incomes (with the exception of a few that better charter us a SWEET private jet for the Creator's convention in Vegas ...), c'est la vie -- let's stop giving this attention it doesn't deserve and get back to churning out some kick-*** themes worth stealing
Last edited by TCcentex; 05-20-2010 at 11:12 AM.
05-20-2010, 10:25 AM #72
@santag, lmao, comparin an iPhone theme with a diaper? lmaoIf you'd like, follow me on Twitter: @16Maarten
Master Theme Creator
05-20-2010, 10:31 AM #73
hahaha maarten you know i meant dialer hahaha. oops i was on my iphone and waling to lab when i typed that up.
TC hahah my themes are all my income right now :P until summer and I get a job haha. but then again i'm not supporting a family haha. and yes I've had people who first got my themes cracked and then ended up paying more for the theme than it actually costs so there are those good people haha. can't wait for vegas baby yeah!!
05-20-2010, 10:51 AM #74
If you'd like, follow me on Twitter: @16Maarten
Master Theme Creator
05-20-2010, 11:00 AM #75
As iŽm affected with my themes:
I had a dicussion with a sinful mod:
The problem is not a leaking beta. People are not to much interessted in betas.
The problem is, how he told me, someone buys it and uploads the final version for all other "members".
So hopefully weŽll find a way to protect our work.
05-20-2010, 01:58 PM #76
Wouldn't there need to be a major overhaul of winterboard and/or all the repos to allow for encrypted licensing of some kind? Even then, someone would figure out a way to crack it. I mean Steve Jobs and the mother ship can't keep iDevices from being jailbroken, I don't honestly see a way to get away from this "problem"
I think I struck a nerve at that other site... This was just put on Maarten's theme thread:
This thread has been HIGHLY edited.
This thread is not a moral values discussion thread.
People, if you feel like trying to change the basis on which xSellize is built apon, then PM an Admin, there is no use and it will get you no where to write 4 huge paragraph's on this thread.
Also, if you have a word to say to Pole22 personally use the PM button.
No more completely off-topic posts will be tolerated on this thread.
I highly respect author's and there creativeness, and personally, i think selling themes is ridiculous and opposite to the reason why we all 'jail-broke' but that is beside the point, What i am saying is we will always enforce Crediting and respect here, and i have added 'buy it if you like it' to the OP.
Feel free to PM me with concerns or questions, but if it is concerning changing what we do here at xSellize (good luck with that) then PM an admin."
and that was after I posted an unsolicited apology for going a little wacko with my opinions, keep in mind I kept it clean and professional, was just expressing my view on the subject
Last edited by TCcentex; 05-22-2010 at 11:27 PM. Reason: Automerged Doublepost
The Following User Says Thank You to TCcentex For This Useful Post:
05-20-2010, 01:59 PM #77
Just saw it, kinda happy they did something 'bout it thoughIf you'd like, follow me on Twitter: @16Maarten
Master Theme Creator
05-20-2010, 02:16 PM #78
I never understood why you parasites charge for themes anyway.
As someone said in an earlier post it is a "hobby" not a business.
Pisses me off to hear you all whining about so called "pirates".
Release your themes for free (as this modding scene is supposedly all about), and you solve the problem.
05-20-2010, 02:19 PM #79
05-20-2010, 02:19 PM #80
wouldn't it be nice to get some back of all the time and effort you put in a theme? I think, for most themes, it's well deserved. We, theme creators, work our *sses off to make themes, and I believe a contribution would be on it's placeIf you'd like, follow me on Twitter: @16Maarten
Master Theme Creator