Download the newest tiny umbrella and plug ya phone in and see what shsh blobs ya got saved if ya have 4.3.3 on there you can go to 4.3.3 if not ya stuck there or upgrade to 5.0.1
You would have to open up redsnow and check boot with tethered evertime the phone restarts. Now if he is away from the computer and it happens then the phone is useless. And yes you can downgrade back to 4.1 if needed.
I would also run TU again and make sure you also check the check box labeled request shsh from Cydia on advanced tab and then click save shsh on general tab..I'm curious when the phone was jailbroken...Cydia may have more blobs for u...I would check just to make sure...
Having some more problems, decided to go for the 5.0 tethered jailbreak and unlock.
Got redsn0w and 5.0 iphone 3gs fw, clicked extras, custom ipsw, browsed to my 5.0 3gs fw, it created a no_bb fw file, clicked pwned dfu, it said done, alt clicked on restore in itunes, browsed to no_bb fw and it popped up with "This device isn’t eligible for the requested build".
Guessing it has something to do with it having the ipad baseband? How can i upgrade to ios 5.0 and keep my unlock and jailbreak?
right, created a custom 4.1 fw with sn0wbreeze, selected ios5.0 with redsn0w and pwned booted 3gs, selected custom fw with itunes, hangs at preparing iphone for restore with the apple logo on the iphone screen, then i get an error 1601.