Both the matte and the white are great cases for different reasons.
I have them both.
The white is great cause it allows me to enjoy the white of my phone without leaving it exposed to getting damaged.
It also has Clear/White rubber so it doesnt leave black marks on the phone like the matte black and other colors.
The matte black doesnt leave any lint and has a great feel to it!
Its very sleek!
Both cases fit very snug on my phone (16gb) but the 16 is known to be alil thicker then the 8 so I guess thats why.
I actually had to take an exacto knife and shave alil off the underside of the top edge of the case so it wouldnt push up on my Steinheil screen protector...