• Your favorite








    , and
  • RIM, Nokia Fire Back at Apple

    As expected, the smartphone manufacturers that Apple dragged into its own iPhone 4 reception mess have not responded favorably to the sweeping accusations made by Apple chief Steve Jobs during Friday's much talked about press conference. During the presentation in which Jobs announced a free case distribution program for iPhone 4 owners, a very large target was made out of Apple's biggest competitors in the smartphone marketplace.

    Alluding to the infamous Death Grip, Jobs said this sort of thing "doesn't just happen to the iPhone." In fact, he boldly asserted that the likes of "Nokia, Motorola and other phones" have the same nagging issue. He then went on to demonstrate how the BlackBerry Bold 9700 and the Samsung Omnia II similarly lose bars when held improperly. Following the presentation, Apple.com unveiled a whole new wing to the site that is pretty much exclusively dedicated to explaining that other smartphones also have fatal reception problems. In fact, this is just about the most attention Apple has ever given to its competition. Of course, none of this attention is positive. And, as a result, there are some angry executives at competing companies that are firing back at Cupertino less than twenty-four hours since Apple fired the first shot.

    Mike Lazaridis and Jim Balsillie - the CEOs of RIM (the makers of Blackberry) - issued a formal and scathing response to Apple's harsh critiques.

    Apple's attempt to draw RIM into Apple's self-made debacle is unacceptable. Apple's claims about RIM products appear to be deliberate attempts to distort the public's understanding of an antenna design issue and to deflect attention from Apple's difficult situation. RIM is a global leader in antenna design and has been successfully designing industry-leading wireless data products with efficient and effective radio performance for over 20 years. During that time, RIM has avoided designs like the one Apple used in the iPhone 4 and instead has used innovative designs which reduce the risk for dropped calls, especially in areas of lower coverage. One thing is for certain, RIM's customers don't need to use a case for their BlackBerry smartphone to maintain proper connectivity. Apple clearly made certain design decisions and it should take responsibility for these decisions rather than trying to draw RIM and others into a situation that relates specifically to Apple.
    Shortly after RIM's chief executives issued choice words to Apple, Nokia followed suit, offering the following:

    Antenna design is a complex subject and has been a core competence at Nokia for decades, across hundreds of phone models. Nokia was the pioneer in internal antennas; the Nokia 8810, launched in 1998, was the first commercial phone with this feature. Nokia has invested thousands of man hours in studying human behavior, including how people hold their phones for calls, music playing, web browsing and so on. As you would expect from a company focused on connecting people, we prioritize antenna performance over physical design if they are ever in conflict. In general, antenna performance of a mobile device/phone may be affected with a tight grip, depending on how the device is held. That’s why Nokia designs our phones to ensure acceptable performance in all real life cases, for example when the phone is held in either hand. Nokia has invested thousands of man hours in studying how people hold their phones and allows for this in designs, for example by having antennas both at the top and bottom of the phone and by careful selection of materials and their use in the mechanical design.
    Other smartphone makers tossed under the bus by Apple are yet to respond. But something tells us they are hard at work this weekend preparing a well-crafted response to the far-reaching jabs Apple took on Friday to distract from the iPhone 4 "Death Grip" that Steve Jobs maintains is vastly overblown in the press.

    This article was originally published in forum thread: RIM, Nokia Fire Back at Apple started by Michael Essany View original post
    Comments 248 Comments
    1. McMike's Avatar
      McMike -
      I'm holding my phone, bumperless, in the "death grip" right now..... and I have 5 bars.

      Yeah, Apple could have handled it better, but get a bumper or get a refund and drop it already.
    1. leathelisor's Avatar
      leathelisor -
      I am no expert on other phones BUT i know 10-15 adults and a couple of friends who have blackbery's and they've never complained EVER about reception. Also i agree with RIM Exec. Apple throwing other companies under the bus is wrong, aren't they supposed to have the BEST phone? But now i'm tagged as a hater by some. O well, ill go bac to my San Fransisco house, drink a Starbucks frapp and play on my mac and pretend everything is alright like the rest of u fanbois.
    1. whereswaldo's Avatar
      whereswaldo -
      I tried it on my brothers Blackberry Bold 9700, and Steve was right!
    1. southfrisco's Avatar
      southfrisco -
      Well here is a Motorola Droid X with the problem...or so it seems...although the video is kind of crappy and shot by a child who somehow got his dad's phone .

      [ame=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kFc9vnocIzQ]YouTube - Antenna Issue with Droid X[/ame]
    1. rocky5's Avatar
      rocky5 -
      Here is my GF's Sony Ericsson K800i this bugger never looses signal.

      I must say my iPhone sitting in the same place and has less bars. (same network)

      now as you can see in the shot taken with my 3Gs that she has 4 bars out of 5 constant.

      now on my 3Gs you can see i have 2 bars and I'm on iOS4 (so I'm meant to have more than i should)

      in general iPhone have crap reception there built to be a phone last.

      now don't get me wrong i love my 3Gs cant see my self leaving it as i have spent a lot of money on apps from the app store, but i would have left this long ago if it wasn't for the app store in my eye this saved the iPhone and still does to this day.
    1. topless1967stang's Avatar
      topless1967stang -
      Apple only has a few years of making phones. They have no right to try and bring RIM and Nokia in to Apple's mistake.

      Steve reminds me of an immature kid that finally says he made a mistake, but he has to say others make mistakes to, just to make himself try to feel and look better.
    1. xNEOxGENESISx's Avatar
      xNEOxGENESISx -
      Honestly, I really have lost trust in apple. Thank God my 3GS works fine but... How can I trust apple products from now on why their way of dealing such important issues is just pointing fingers at others?
      Just so unfortunate.
    1. snoopyrph's Avatar
      snoopyrph -
      People said they didn't have that problem with death grip and and have 5 bars on it because they are the area with much signal. Try where you have 2or 3 bars and you see what happens. I tested myself and that's the fact. Place like ATT and Apple store, they boost their signal so strong that it will not affect the Death grip.
    1. pacmac's Avatar
      pacmac -
      anyone watched the signal video on apple website? i notice they dont let the phone signal drop dead they get it to 1 bar then let go right away..other phones they seem to hold it longer..

      my fix for iphone 4 would be make the antenna internal all the way around inside the frame were it cant be touched/bridge and make the frame one piece with no rubber gaps..
    1. ro0oney's Avatar
      ro0oney -
      apple should already stop with the "other phones antenna problems" and face it that their phone has a poor engineering design.
      this is my first time hearing about an antenna problem. i didn't know that and "antenna" existed till i meet the iphone 4
    1. atm_10142k's Avatar
      atm_10142k -
      Quote Originally Posted by paganizonda83 View Post
      I did find it interesting that he named nokia and motorola yet he didn't give any examples for either of the two, nor does the website. Being that they are two huge names in the global cell market you would think that it would be a given to show they're victims of the same problems.
      Why does apple explain other phone issues. They are just pissed that Apple is presenting to everyone that the media chooses not to. This editor from this website seems to be all anti Apple.
      Why cant we all just get along.

      Check out this video on you tube it may make you smile .... a little for those anti-apple.
    1. hancoma's Avatar
      hancoma -
      First off:
      My wife has the death grip issue, but only if I grip exceedingly tighter than normal.
      However, EVERY IPHONE, or any phone I have ever had I always buy a case for....everyone I have ever seen with an iphone has a case for it.
      Seriously, I have never seen anyone use their Iphone without a case.
      I believe Apple chose design over functionality with this current iteration of Iphone builds...assuming everyone would have cases and not be an issue.
      For all others that do not have a case and use their Iphone without one because they enjoy the 'sleek, sexy' feel...I agree the issue should be resolved, but will the 'recall' or 'fix' be one that reduces the enjoyment of the 'sleek, sexy' device?
      BTW I also have a Blackberry, and was able to duplicate a 'death grip', but only if I held the phone in a way that is out of the norm.
      This is an industry issue, but is exacerbated by Apple with design over functionality.
    1. atm_10142k's Avatar
      atm_10142k -
      Quote Originally Posted by Luppin View Post
      Thank god RIM called Apple out on their BS. I really can't believe that a multi-billion dollar international corporation like Apple would resort to "Antenna issue? Oh, well uh.....HAY LOOK AT THESE OTHER PHONES!!! THEY HAVE RECEPTION ISSUES TOO!! A Fix? Oh, well uh.....FREE CASES, FOR EVERYONE!!" And what was hilarious was when one of the reporters there sat there with his Blackberry Bold during the Q&A and was unable to replicate the reception issue, all Steve Jobs could say was "You may not see it in certain areas." So the Blackberry Bold (which Apple bashed in their press conference) only has reception issues in 100 million dollar testing facilities, while the iPhone 4 only has reception issues everywhere else on the face of the planet? Really don't see myself buying the iPhone 5 after all this.
      Yea he did he not have any issue. Like Jobs and other have said it happens in weak reception areas ONLY !!!!!!!!!. Sure lets distort the facts that were stated. Hey let's just make up a new story. If you don't like your iphone for take it back.
    1. zmanforever's Avatar
      zmanforever -
      Quote Originally Posted by southfrisco View Post
      Well here is a Motorola Droid X with the problem...or so it seems...although the video is kind of crappy and shot by a child who somehow got his dad's phone .

      YouTube - Antenna Issue with Droid X
      Um yea in the video the kid is using a damaged Droid X and is getting a replacement soon.

      Read the youtube comments to confirm, that video does not count since they are giving him a brand new Droid X, he is showing off a damaged phone.

      In the comments many are telling him to change the name to Damaged Droid X.

      And I have a iPhone 4 I will never touch Android, because I like Cydia.
    1. Venom1234's Avatar
      Venom1234 -
      Quote Originally Posted by spiderguy84 View Post
      Spoken like a true idiot. Got to love the philosophy of, if I'm not happy with a statistic then I will just call whoever said the number a liar. I personally believe everything that the RIM CEO said to be a lie. Everyone knows it's total BS. Just a bunch of blabber from a moron who will spout off personal opinions unverifiable statements such as the iPhone would never sell if it wasn't for jailbreaking. Give me a break idiot.
      Lol I'm an idiot lol your argument don't even justify what your saying..you sir fail at life, go suck the apple tit some more. We all know the dropped call percent and return rate percent at the meeting yesterday was total ******** and made up by apple.
    1. atm_10142k's Avatar
      atm_10142k -
      Quote Originally Posted by rocky5 View Post
      The only reason I bought an iPod touch, iPhone 3G and my 3Gs and when I say bought I mean full price no contract crap.

      But I know that apple are not a good company every one knows, they pick on little companies willy-nilly or any one that questions them.

      In my eyes
      Macs = simplicity
      PC's = user choice, advanced

      But this is my opinion I will never purchase a mac as I have no need, no pc crashes no slowdown pc runs super quick and I can play the latest games all for half the price of a basic mac.

      So unless your not a comp guru or you just want something that you can flaunt about and say hey look at me I bought a mac then get one.

      And I know this because my M8 wants one not for it's performance or the OS but to say I HAVE A MAC which I find sad.

      I don't go about shouting I have a iPhone, loooooook at meeeeeeee I'm amazing.

      IPhone great device but not so good phone lol you know it has to perform 100% at being a phone, if it doesn't then it's just an iPot wrongly named.
      I thought this feed was the Iphone 4 issue the editor from this website chooses not to let go.
      Now its about PC versus MAC from what this person said.
    1. GrandMstrBud's Avatar
      GrandMstrBud -
      If Apple were to release a macbook with dead pixels and come up with a solution like a free VGA cable so you can hook it up to an external monitor and there would be people out there that would accept it as a solution. It's pretty sad how people will stick up for Apple and think they can do no wrong.
    1. bluexselvedge's Avatar
      bluexselvedge -
      Quote Originally Posted by Teoyaomqui View Post
      I'll be doing the same.

      iPhone4 is my last apple product I'll ever buy and am even thinking of returning it.

      That was just plain wrong.

      Their credibility got shatter.
      might as well go return it soon to avoid any fees.
    1. zmanforever's Avatar
      zmanforever -
      Apple relating other phones to say they are the same antenna problems is not so far out, they want to make the Apple image to the investors seem more clean.

      Yesterdays conference and press being shown the secret Apple Black Labs was to do all of this, just make the investors happier.

      Sure this is a problem and if it is to much for you to handle and just can not grasp the idea of using a 30$ item to protect your at minimum 199$ investment from bad signal grip issues, and now since the case will be free and you can still not handle covering a iPhone 4 with a case well return it for full refund.
    1. luisd79's Avatar
      luisd79 -
      you know the you tube song they had at the beginning of yesterdays press con that is a great song to describe all you people, Jobs was just showing idiots like you guys that other phones had the same problem and no one made a big deal with them like they did with apple ,no one really said any thing about the one hour my girl gets with her evo and at least you dont see any of the apple buttons fall of like the rim ball fall out of the stupid black berry