• Your favorite








    , and
  • Is AT&T Capping Your Upload Speed?

    Reports are spreading that upload throughput over 3G is being throttled, in many cases to as little as 100 kb. [ame="http://forums.macrumors.com/showthread.php?t=960232"]MacRumors[/ame] and Gizmodo are both reporting the speed test results of users on their forums, and complaints have been appearing on Apple's Support forums as well. The throughput drops are are especially noticeable given that many users had specific data of much improved uploads using the iPhone 4, and have fed speculation that AT&T has imposed caps. Neither Apple nor AT&T have returned requests for comment as of this writing.

    When the iPhone 4 was released, users (including me) found a dramatic throughput increase, particularly on uploads. Support for HSUPA improved uploads to 1.5 Mb/s or greater where iPhone 3GSes were getting a maximum of 384 kb/s. Over the weekend, though forum users began posting on MacRumors that uploads had been throttled hard. Users in areas throughout the US were seeing the slowdown, with reports coming in from major metropolitan aareas like New York/New Jersey, Suffolk County/Long Island, Boston, Las Vegas, Houston, Philadelphia/South Jersey, Denver and Washington D.C. as well as smaller cities like Columbus, Cleveland, Northern Colorado, St. Paul, and Kansas City.

    I tested my throughput using the Speedtest.net app at the beginning of last week and saw uploads in the 1.2 Mb/s range. Today I'm seeing the same, and I'm just north of downtown Boston. So there's a possibility that what was seen was a temporary overload of AT&T's network due to people uploading a lot of holiday videos to Facebook, or another AT&T FAIL. We'll have to see what develops, and what AT&T's response is, but meanwhile, please let me know what your upload speed is in comments, especially if you have before/after comparisons from last week.
    This article was originally published in forum thread: Is AT&T Capping Your Upload Speed? started by Paul Daniel Ash View original post
    Comments 94 Comments
    1. CaptainChaos's Avatar
      CaptainChaos -
      How is this an AT&T fail? It's not like any carrier has as solid a network as say a cable ISP. They should throttle. Why tax the network for everyone when throttling will provide a more stable experience for the masses?
    1. adp's Avatar
      adp -
      1.25Mbps Down
      0.93Mbps Up

      Location: South FL

      Seems to be fine here
    1. Poseidon79's Avatar
      Poseidon79 -
      2.32Mb down and 1.2Mb up here in Austin.
    1. tyson1749's Avatar
      tyson1749 -
      Mine were 3500/4000 dwn and 1100/1400 up last week. Now 1400/2000 dwn and 150/220 up through the weekend into today. Definitely something going on. Btw I'm in Portland, OR
    1. HarlemState's Avatar
      HarlemState -
      Live near Central Park, and my results were, DL,2.39mbps....UL,0.17mbps... on 3g, forgot the results from last week sry
    1. RICO_'s Avatar
      RICO_ -
      If this were indeed true....... Would it seriously surprise any of you? Especially after what they did with the ridiculous new data plan packages.

      This is why I've delayed my iPhone 4 upgrade. Just seems to me like AT&T is doin more and more to piss off their customers and screw them over. I'm just waiting on the next thing they decide to do that pushes me over the top. I keep thinking they will improve and get better, but Im seriously doubting that right now. I've had more dropped calls now than I ever had before with either AT&T or any other service provider. And funny how this dramatic increase in dropped calls for me occured right around the same time that AT&T stopped advertising their "switch to the network with the fewest dropped calls" slogan.
    1. KartRacer's Avatar
      KartRacer -
      I don't want to hear any ********! I just got 145 max down, 46 max up and 414ms latency.
    1. kuhndsn's Avatar
      kuhndsn -
      I'm actually a little faster.

      2.54 down
      1.10 up

      Atown Texas
    1. mumra06's Avatar
      mumra06 -
      2.69 down and 1.22 up in Waco Texas

      but 10 minutes later

      0.75 down 0.56 up

    1. Pntbllfrk's Avatar
      Pntbllfrk -

      Speeds went DOWN in my area, I do not have a comparison due to reinstall of the APP,
      but my 3g here in Columbia, Tennessee is

      203 kbps download
      6 kbps upload
    1. x2dope's Avatar
      x2dope -
      About 8 months ago my download was 2.5mb and 500kb upload now my download is 500k and my upload is 1.2 I dont really know but I am pretty sure att is trottling the download in my area which is ******** considering im paying 30 dollars a month for such ****** download that use to be awesome. but on an even worse note verizon use to be 1mbps slower than att and now its 1mbps FASTER than att where i live...this really pisses me off.
    1. turdsmoka's Avatar
      turdsmoka -
      My upload speeds are less than 100kb, was 1400kb last week. Then again, we added a lot of Iphone4 units this week, too.
    1. Plotkin35's Avatar
      Plotkin35 -
      Now I'm pissed. I'm a still grandfathered in for unlimited data, just ran tests and I'm getting:

      402 kpbs Download and only 43 kbps upload......I'm in Boston, MA Will try testing a few more times, but

      second test just did and now I have 1996 down and 223 up
    1. TheDirtyDiddler's Avatar
      TheDirtyDiddler -
      iPhone 4 in New Haven, CT

      532 kbps DOWN

      910 kbps UP

    1. Teban's Avatar
      Teban -
      Boston last week 1.2 d 1.1 u
      Just now 93k d 511k u
      2 mins later 1.1 d 1.2 u
    1. ramicio's Avatar
      ramicio -
      Who cares? If they want to cap their network to make it more usable, then that's good. I'd rather have a slower connection than an intermittent one. What does one need a few Mbps upload on a mobile phone for anyway? A phone is a phone, and it's cool to have one with internet, but it's still not a computer, and I wish technology would stop trying to bridge the gap and turn everything into the matrix. My internet at home is only 768 kbps, so I think if they capped it to around 250 kbps, that would be fine by me.
    1. jamp1483's Avatar
      jamp1483 -
      Location Charlotte NC
      DWNLD 326 Kbps
      Uplad. 737 Kbps sucks
    1. punjabi212's Avatar
      punjabi212 -
      How do you check the speed?
    1. integra93_4's Avatar
      integra93_4 -
      at 2:50 PM 07/06/2010 Secaucus, NJ
      Download 2.18
      Upload 0.09 MPS

      I think it's true - AT&T is putting the cap on upload
    1. CaptainChaos's Avatar
      CaptainChaos -
      Quote Originally Posted by punjabi212 View Post
      How do you check the speed?
      Download Speedtest.net.

      I have 2.1mb down 457 up